[Mod Please Close] So... Chaotic long vs Chaotic Rapier vs Chaotic Maul

Rapier!

I would say rapier for training combat, longsword for fun things like boss hunting, c wars.
Rapier is still good for those other things too, so unless you plan to boss hunt often I would go with rapier.

So conclusive, if you are an allround player buy rapier. If you want to do specific stuff, buy all 3? :p

Depends on what you're going to do with it. If you're just going to be training combat in general, then the rapier is perfect. It's accurate and can speed up slayer tasks so much. It's especialy noticeable during dragon tasks where the stab option comes in really handy.
If you're going to be doing alot of boss hunting such as tormented demons or Bandos then I've heard that the cls can be really useful there. Some teams also have requirements for a chaotic such as cls, so that could be useful.
Finally I think the maul is mostly used of PKing or PvP in general because of its high hits, so really it depends on what you like doing most on RS.
Personally, I'd recommend the rapier as your first chaotic. It can be used for most melee combat situations whether it be training or bossing so I reckon it's more useful than the others. You'll be able to get tokens faster at higher dg levels anyway when you can buy the rest of the chaotics, but for the time being I think the rapier will serve you well.

You should get what you want. You seem to like the CLS, so get it. Its still better than a whip. When I had it, I liked it because of the high hits, and decent speed. If you dont really care about which is better xp in the long run, get the cls. I enjoyed it alot more than the rapier, even though the rapier is statistically better.

I went with the Rapier. Next is going to be Chaotic c'bow then cls.